# JEV-002 — Stale rationale after changing a choice Status: Queued. PR: Pending. ## Problem and evidence Chat attributed exception grouping and stack traces to Sentry. Saving Sentry produced matching prose. After reopening and selecting manually added OpenTelemetry with Grafana, the replacement paragraph named Grafana but retained that rationale without new Grafana evidence. Observed in the [live browser pass](../jev-live-browser-test.md). `apps/server/src/conversation-plan/prose-job.ts` filters reasons and passes the previous paragraph to `prosePrompt()`. This is a candidate boundary, not a proven root cause. ## Concrete reproduction 1. Propose Sentry with exception grouping and stack-trace rationale; save it. 2. Reopen and manually add/select OpenTelemetry with Grafana, with no rationale that attributes those capabilities to Grafana. 3. Save and inspect the replacement paragraph and its generation prompt. ## Expected behavior and scope Ground prose in the current choice and applicable sourced reasons. Replace prior prose without copying unsupported reasons belonging to the previous option. Scope is reason provenance and prose prompt/generation; anchor lifecycle belongs to JEV-001, and extraction/review policy to JEV-003. ## Acceptance checks - Deterministic provenance/prompt coverage excludes old-option-only rationale. - Supported shared/current-choice reasons remain available. - Replacement produces one current-choice passage. - Targeted browser/provider check where practical, with model limits documented. - Separate implementer, independent tester and reviewer; individual fix PR. ## Implementation, verification and limits Queued. Candidate boundary only; provider quality and first cause unconfirmed.