{ "version": 1, "asOf": "2026-09-19", "description": "User-informed calibration priors and synthetic scoring contracts. No entry is a measured quality verdict. Synthetic fixtures contain invented evidence and must never enter the catalog.", "policy": { "ratingsExcluded": true, "ratingCountsExcluded": true, "targetsNeverEnterScoring": true, "renownCapPoints": 5, "renownCombination": "max-per-entity; deduplicate the same recognition event and do not copy author or series recognition into every child", "cadenceAloneChangesCraft": false, "unknownIsNotLow": true, "syntheticFixturesAreBlindHoldout": false, "realLowQualityAnchorAvailable": false }, "anchors": [ { "id": "dcc-high", "entityType": "series", "entityId": "dungeon-crawler-carl", "title": "Dungeon Crawler Carl", "author": "Matt Dinniman", "target": { "min": 85, "max": 100, "metric": "craft", "basis": "agent-guestimate-from-user-high-anchor", "evaluated": false }, "notes": [ "User supplied the qualitative high-quality anchor; this broad numeric range is a proposed calibration band, not an empirical result.", "Do not apply the target to every volume or to unrelated Matt Dinniman works." ], "evidenceIds": [ "dcc-bam-2025", "dcc-prh-nyt" ] }, { "id": "cradle-high", "entityType": "series", "entityId": "cradle", "title": "Cradle", "author": "Will Wight", "target": { "min": 85, "max": 100, "metric": "craft", "basis": "agent-guestimate-from-user-high-anchor", "evaluated": false }, "notes": [ "User supplied the qualitative high-quality anchor; the numeric band is an agent guestimate.", "Assess early and late books separately; book-one evidence cannot establish the whole-series trajectory." ], "evidenceIds": [ "cradle-author-nyt", "dreadgod-audible-2022" ] }, { "id": "primal-hunter-high", "entityType": "series", "entityId": "the-primal-hunter", "title": "The Primal Hunter", "author": "Zogarth", "target": { "min": 80, "max": 95, "metric": "craft", "basis": "agent-guestimate-from-user-high-anchor", "evaluated": false }, "notes": [ "User supplied the qualitative high-quality anchor; the numeric band is an agent guestimate.", "Author-disclosed serialization cadence is context, not negative craft evidence." ], "evidenceIds": [ "primal-aethon-charts-2023", "primal-serial-cadence" ] }, { "id": "heretical-fishing-upper-mid", "entityType": "series", "entityId": "heretical-fishing", "title": "Heretical Fishing", "author": "Haylock Jobson", "target": { "min": 60, "max": 79, "metric": "craft", "basis": "agent-guestimate-from-user-upper-mid-anchor", "evaluated": false }, "trendHypothesis": { "direction": "declining", "basis": "user-report", "independentlyVerified": false }, "notes": [ "The user described upper-mid quality and later falloff; no independent volume-specific confirmation is claimed.", "Do not penalize deliberate cozy pacing or fishing subject matter." ], "evidenceIds": [ "heretical-podium-identity" ] } ], "renownEvidence": [ { "id": "dcc-bam-2025", "entityType": "book", "entityId": "work-dungeon-crawler-carl-1", "title": "Dungeon Crawler Carl", "recognitionKey": "books-a-million:book-of-the-year:2025", "kind": "retailer-editorial-selection", "claim": "Books-A-Million selected Dungeon Crawler Carl as its inaugural 2025 Book of the Year.", "sourceUrl": "https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/books-a-million-names-dungeon-crawler-carl-as-inaugural-book-of-the-year-302604458.html", "sourceName": "Books-A-Million, Inc.", "sourceRelation": "originating-retailer-announcement", "observedAt": "2026-09-19", "publishedAt": "2025-11-04", "eventDate": "2025-11-04", "dateMeaning": "Selection announced on this date.", "limitations": [ "Bookseller editorial enthusiasm; not a juried literary or audiobook-performance award.", "Recognition is directly of book one; do not copy it independently to each series volume." ], "assessment": { "score": 60, "confidence": 0.95, "evidenceIds": [ "dcc-bam-2025" ], "basis": "independent-recognition" } }, { "id": "dcc-prh-nyt", "entityType": "book", "entityId": "work-dungeon-crawler-carl-1", "title": "Dungeon Crawler Carl", "recognitionKey": "nyt:bestseller:dungeon-crawler-carl:date-unknown", "kind": "publisher-reported-bestseller", "claim": "Penguin Random House describes this book as a New York Times bestseller.", "sourceUrl": "https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/772002/dungeon-crawler-carl-by-matt-dinniman/", "sourceName": "Penguin Random House", "sourceRelation": "publisher-claim", "observedAt": "2026-09-19", "publishedAt": null, "eventDate": null, "dateMeaning": "Chart date and rank were not established; edition publication dates must not substitute.", "limitations": [ "Not independently checked against the originating New York Times chart.", "A bestseller is market recognition, not direct craftsmanship evidence." ], "assessment": { "score": 40, "confidence": 0.8, "evidenceIds": [ "dcc-prh-nyt" ], "basis": "editorial-reference" } }, { "id": "cradle-author-nyt", "entityType": "series", "entityId": "cradle", "title": "Cradle", "recognitionKey": "nyt:bestseller:cradle-series:date-unknown", "kind": "author-reported-bestseller", "claim": "Will Wight's official series page describes Cradle as a New York Times bestselling series.", "sourceUrl": "https://www.willwight.com/cradle.html", "sourceName": "Will Wight / Hidden Gnome Publishing", "sourceRelation": "author-publisher-claim", "observedAt": "2026-09-19", "publishedAt": null, "eventDate": null, "dateMeaning": "The page does not establish a chart date or claim that every volume charted.", "limitations": [ "Series claim, not a credential for every book or the author's unrelated series.", "Not independently checked against an originating New York Times chart." ], "assessment": { "score": 40, "confidence": 0.8, "evidenceIds": [ "cradle-author-nyt" ], "basis": "editorial-reference" } }, { "id": "dreadgod-audible-2022", "entityType": "book", "entityId": "work-cradle-11", "title": "Dreadgod", "recognitionKey": "audible:bestseller:dreadgod:2022-06-21", "kind": "author-reported-chart-position", "claim": "Will Wight reported Dreadgod at number four on Audible's bestseller list during preorder.", "sourceUrl": "https://www.willwight.com/a-blog-of-dubious-intent/dreadgod-pre-order-is-live", "sourceName": "Will Wight / Hidden Gnome Publishing", "sourceRelation": "author-publisher-contemporaneous-claim", "observedAt": "2026-09-19", "publishedAt": "2022-06-21", "eventDate": "2022-06-21", "dateMeaning": "Historical chart position as reported that day, not a current position.", "limitations": [ "Historical preorder chart position, not a juried award.", "Author-reported; original chart snapshot not independently retrieved." ], "assessment": { "score": 40, "confidence": 0.8, "evidenceIds": [ "dreadgod-audible-2022" ], "basis": "editorial-reference" } }, { "id": "primal-aethon-charts-2023", "entityType": "series", "entityId": "the-primal-hunter", "title": "The Primal Hunter", "recognitionKey": "amazon-top-charts:bestseller:primal-hunter:date-unknown", "kind": "publisher-reported-bestseller", "claim": "Aethon describes The Primal Hunter as an Amazon Top Charts bestseller in its WEBTOON adaptation announcement.", "sourceUrl": "https://aethonbooks.com/2023/01/18/aethon-partners-with-webtoon-for-origincomic-adaptations/", "sourceName": "Aethon Books", "sourceRelation": "publisher-claim", "observedAt": "2026-09-19", "publishedAt": "2023-01-18", "eventDate": null, "dateMeaning": "The announcement date is known; the underlying chart event date and position are not.", "limitations": [ "Publisher-reported market visibility; not direct evidence of craft.", "Adaptation, web-serial readership, and repeated publisher blurbs must not stack as independent craft recognition." ], "assessment": { "score": 40, "confidence": 0.8, "evidenceIds": [ "primal-aethon-charts-2023" ], "basis": "editorial-reference" } } ], "contextEvidence": [ { "id": "primal-serial-cadence", "entityType": "series", "entityId": "the-primal-hunter", "kind": "author-disclosed-serialization", "claim": "The author listing states five chapters per week and an average chapter length of 2,500 words.", "sourceUrl": "https://www.royalroad.com/fiction/36049/the-primal-hunter", "sourceName": "Zogarth on Royal Road", "observedAt": "2026-09-19", "publishedAt": null, "qualityEffect": 0, "inference": "If sustained, that announced rate is approximately 100,000 words in eight weeks. This is arithmetic from a stated schedule, not measured output." }, { "id": "wight-overlapping-drafts-2023", "entityType": "author", "entityId": null, "author": "Will Wight", "kind": "overlapping-production", "claim": "A January 31, 2023 progress post says Waybound and the new space-fantasy book are both nearing draft completion; the March 2 announcement gives The Captain April 4 and Waybound June 6 release dates.", "sourceUrls": [ "https://www.willwight.com/a-blog-of-dubious-intent/archives/01-2023", "https://www.willwight.com/a-blog-of-dubious-intent/announcing-the-captain-and-nothing-else" ], "sourceName": "Will Wight / Hidden Gnome Publishing", "observedAt": "2026-09-19", "publishedAt": [ "2023-01-31", "2023-03-02" ], "qualityEffect": 0, "inference": "A 63-day publication interval cannot be interpreted as 63 days spent composing the later novel." }, { "id": "heretical-podium-identity", "entityType": "series", "entityId": "heretical-fishing", "kind": "publisher-series-identity", "claim": "Podium identifies Heretical Fishing by Haylock Jobson, narrated by Heath Miller, with the first release dated March 12, 2024.", "sourceUrl": "https://podiumentertainment.com/series/1893/heretical-fishing", "sourceName": "Podium Entertainment", "observedAt": "2026-09-19", "publishedAt": null, "qualityEffect": 0, "renownEligible": false, "exclusionReason": "Royal Road Rising Star marketing is not used because the ranking mechanism has not been shown to exclude ratings." } ], "disclosureControls": [ { "id": "royal-road-explicit-ai-warning", "entityType": "external-work", "entityId": null, "title": "WORTHLESS: A Dungeon Merchant LitRPG", "author": "Jon Pettner", "sourceUrl": "https://www.royalroad.com/fiction/190302/worthless-a-dungeon-merchant-litrpg", "sourceName": "Author listing on Royal Road", "observedAt": "2026-09-19", "observedDisclosure": "AI-Generated Content", "expected": { "disclosurePresent": true, "craftScore": null, "audiobookConfirmed": false }, "scope": "evidence-format-only", "limitations": [ "This verifies the displayed platform warning only.", "It does not establish the portion of generated prose, craft quality, or an audiobook edition.", "Do not use this title as a low-quality anchor or import it into the audiobook catalog on this evidence." ] }, { "id": "virtual-voice-is-narration", "entityType": "documentation", "entityId": null, "sourceUrl": "https://kdp.amazon.com/en_US/help/topic/GFAQU3LUEHCRB8KD", "sourceName": "Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing", "observedAt": "2026-09-19", "observedDisclosure": "Virtual Voice uses computer-generated speech technology.", "expected": { "narrationDisclosure": true, "aiWritingInference": false, "craftScore": null }, "scope": "evidence-separation-only" } ], "syntheticControls": [ { "id": "strong-craft", "synthetic": true, "kind": "book", "label": "Invented well-crafted book", "input": { "id": "synthetic:strong-craft", "seriesId": "synthetic:control-series", "number": 1, "craftProfile": "profile-1" }, "preferences": { "avoidExplicit": true, "avoidHarem": true, "avoidSexualizedMarketing": true, "useRenown": true, "useCorroboratedProductionRisk": true }, "expected": { "craftMin": 85, "craftMax": 100 } }, { "id": "repetitive-unedited-incoherent", "synthetic": true, "kind": "book", "label": "Invented padding, editing defects, and incoherent progression", "input": { "id": "synthetic:repetitive-unedited-incoherent", "seriesId": "synthetic:control-series", "number": 1, "craftProfile": "profile-2" }, "preferences": { "avoidExplicit": true, "avoidHarem": true, "avoidSexualizedMarketing": true, "useRenown": true, "useCorroboratedProductionRisk": true }, "expected": { "craftMin": 0, "craftMax": 30 }, "invariant": "Low craft follows concrete defects, not a real-author AI allegation." }, { "id": "strong-erotic-craft", "synthetic": true, "kind": "book", "label": "Invented well-crafted erotic fiction", "input": { "id": "synthetic:strong-erotic-craft", "seriesId": "synthetic:control-series", "number": 1, "content": { "explicit": { "verdict": "present", "confidence": 0.95, "evidenceIds": [ "synthetic:publisher-explicit-disclosure" ] } }, "craftProfile": "profile-1" }, "preferences": { "avoidExplicit": true, "avoidHarem": true, "avoidSexualizedMarketing": true, "useRenown": true, "useCorroboratedProductionRisk": true }, "expected": { "craftMin": 85, "craftMax": 100, "indexLessThanCraft": true }, "invariant": "Erotic-content avoidance lowers fit, while craft remains identical to the strong-craft control." }, { "id": "fast-backlog", "synthetic": true, "kind": "book", "label": "Invented strong book in a monthly audiobook backlog release", "input": { "id": "synthetic:fast-backlog", "seriesId": "synthetic:control-series", "number": 1, "production": { "asOf": "2026-09-19", "backlogExcluded": false, "releases": [ { "workId": "synthetic:backlog-1", "date": "2026-01-15", "format": "audiobook", "role": "edition-release", "verified": true, "evidenceIds": [ "synthetic:audio-date-1" ] }, { "workId": "synthetic:backlog-2", "date": "2026-02-15", "format": "audiobook", "role": "edition-release", "verified": true, "evidenceIds": [ "synthetic:audio-date-2" ] }, { "workId": "synthetic:backlog-3", "date": "2026-03-15", "format": "audiobook", "role": "edition-release", "verified": true, "evidenceIds": [ "synthetic:audio-date-3" ] }, { "workId": "synthetic:backlog-4", "date": "2026-04-15", "format": "audiobook", "role": "edition-release", "verified": true, "evidenceIds": [ "synthetic:audio-date-4" ] }, { "workId": "synthetic:backlog-5", "date": "2026-05-15", "format": "audiobook", "role": "edition-release", "verified": true, "evidenceIds": [ "synthetic:audio-date-5" ] }, { "workId": "synthetic:backlog-6", "date": "2026-06-15", "format": "audiobook", "role": "edition-release", "verified": true, "evidenceIds": [ "synthetic:audio-date-6" ] } ] }, "craftProfile": "profile-1" }, "preferences": { "avoidExplicit": true, "avoidHarem": true, "avoidSexualizedMarketing": true, "useRenown": true, "useCorroboratedProductionRisk": true }, "expected": { "craftMin": 85, "craftMax": 100, "noAdjustmentKind": "production-risk" }, "invariant": "Edition-release dates and unexcluded backlog never establish fast original production." }, { "id": "deliberate-cozy-pacing", "synthetic": true, "kind": "book", "label": "Invented deliberate cozy story whose scenes serve its intended structure", "input": { "id": "synthetic:deliberate-cozy-pacing", "seriesId": "synthetic:control-series", "number": 1, "craftProfile": "profile-1" }, "preferences": { "avoidExplicit": true, "avoidHarem": true, "avoidSexualizedMarketing": true, "useRenown": true, "useCorroboratedProductionRisk": true }, "expected": { "craftMin": 85, "craftMax": 100 }, "invariant": "A slow, quiet subject is not by itself a pacing defect." }, { "id": "single-voice", "synthetic": true, "kind": "book", "label": "Invented strong opinion from only one reader", "input": { "id": "synthetic:single-voice", "seriesId": "synthetic:control-series", "number": 1, "craftProfile": "profile-3" }, "preferences": { "avoidExplicit": true, "avoidHarem": true, "avoidSexualizedMarketing": true, "useRenown": true, "useCorroboratedProductionRisk": true }, "expected": { "craftScore": null }, "invariant": "Six aspect labels from the same person do not become six independent voices." }, { "id": "unassessed", "synthetic": true, "kind": "book", "label": "Invented unassessed book", "input": { "id": "synthetic:unassessed", "seriesId": "synthetic:control-series", "number": 1, "craftProfile": "profile-4" }, "preferences": { "avoidExplicit": true, "avoidHarem": true, "avoidSexualizedMarketing": true, "useRenown": true, "useCorroboratedProductionRisk": true }, "expected": { "craftScore": null }, "invariant": "Missing evidence never becomes a low quality verdict." }, { "id": "renown-alone", "synthetic": true, "kind": "book", "label": "Invented acclaimed but unassessed book", "input": { "id": "synthetic:renown-only", "seriesId": "synthetic:control-series", "number": 1, "renown": { "score": 100, "confidence": 1, "evidenceIds": [ "synthetic:recognition" ], "basis": "independent-recognition" }, "craftProfile": "profile-4" }, "preferences": { "avoidExplicit": true, "avoidHarem": true, "avoidSexualizedMarketing": true, "useRenown": true, "useCorroboratedProductionRisk": true }, "expected": { "craftScore": null, "indexScore": null }, "invariant": "Recognition cannot create a craft score when evidence is absent." }, { "id": "rating-invariance", "synthetic": true, "kind": "book", "label": "Same invented evidence with a perfect star score and a million ratings", "input": { "id": "synthetic:strong-craft", "seriesId": "synthetic:control-series", "number": 1, "rating": 5, "ratingCount": 1000000, "craftProfile": "profile-1" }, "preferences": { "avoidExplicit": true, "avoidHarem": true, "avoidSexualizedMarketing": true, "useRenown": true, "useCorroboratedProductionRisk": true }, "expected": { "sameCraftAs": "strong-craft", "sameIndexAs": "strong-craft" }, "invariant": "Star ratings and rating counts are ignored even when present as extraneous input fields." }, { "id": "series-falloff", "synthetic": true, "kind": "series", "label": "Invented series with comparable early and late craft evidence", "input": { "id": "synthetic:falloff-series", "books": [ { "id": "synthetic:falloff-1", "seriesId": "synthetic:falloff-series", "number": 1, "craftProfile": "profile-5" }, { "id": "synthetic:falloff-2", "seriesId": "synthetic:falloff-series", "number": 2, "craftProfile": "profile-6" }, { "id": "synthetic:falloff-3", "seriesId": "synthetic:falloff-series", "number": 3, "craftProfile": "profile-7" }, { "id": "synthetic:falloff-4", "seriesId": "synthetic:falloff-series", "number": 4, "craftProfile": "profile-8" } ], "knownWorkCount": 4, "catalogComplete": true }, "preferences": { "avoidExplicit": true, "avoidHarem": true, "avoidSexualizedMarketing": true, "useRenown": true, "useCorroboratedProductionRisk": true }, "expected": { "trend": "declining" }, "adapter": "Score each BookQualityInput before passing it to scoreSeries; these are inputs, not stored results." }, { "id": "author-series-balance", "synthetic": true, "kind": "author", "label": "Invented author with one prolific weak series and one small strong series", "input": { "id": "synthetic:balanced-author", "series": [ { "id": "synthetic:prolific-series", "books": [ { "id": "synthetic:prolific-1", "seriesId": "synthetic:prolific-series", "number": 1, "craftProfile": "profile-9" }, { "id": "synthetic:prolific-2", "seriesId": "synthetic:prolific-series", "number": 2, "craftProfile": "profile-9" }, { "id": "synthetic:prolific-3", "seriesId": "synthetic:prolific-series", "number": 3, "craftProfile": "profile-9" }, { "id": "synthetic:prolific-4", "seriesId": "synthetic:prolific-series", "number": 4, "craftProfile": "profile-9" }, { "id": "synthetic:prolific-5", "seriesId": "synthetic:prolific-series", "number": 5, "craftProfile": "profile-9" }, { "id": "synthetic:prolific-6", "seriesId": "synthetic:prolific-series", "number": 6, "craftProfile": "profile-9" }, { "id": "synthetic:prolific-7", "seriesId": "synthetic:prolific-series", "number": 7, "craftProfile": "profile-9" }, { "id": "synthetic:prolific-8", "seriesId": "synthetic:prolific-series", "number": 8, "craftProfile": "profile-9" }, { "id": "synthetic:prolific-9", "seriesId": "synthetic:prolific-series", "number": 9, "craftProfile": "profile-9" }, { "id": "synthetic:prolific-10", "seriesId": "synthetic:prolific-series", "number": 10, "craftProfile": "profile-9" }, { "id": "synthetic:prolific-11", "seriesId": "synthetic:prolific-series", "number": 11, "craftProfile": "profile-9" }, { "id": "synthetic:prolific-12", "seriesId": "synthetic:prolific-series", "number": 12, "craftProfile": "profile-9" } ], "knownWorkCount": 12, "catalogComplete": true }, { "id": "synthetic:small-series", "books": [ { "id": "synthetic:small-1", "seriesId": "synthetic:small-series", "number": 1, "craftProfile": "profile-1" }, { "id": "synthetic:small-2", "seriesId": "synthetic:small-series", "number": 2, "craftProfile": "profile-1" } ], "knownWorkCount": 2, "catalogComplete": true } ], "knownSeriesCount": 2, "catalogComplete": true }, "preferences": { "avoidExplicit": true, "avoidHarem": true, "avoidSexualizedMarketing": true, "useRenown": true, "useCorroboratedProductionRisk": true }, "expected": { "craftMin": 70, "craftMax": 80 }, "adapter": "Score books then series before scoreAuthor; equal-quality series should have equal influence regardless of their book counts." } ], "openGaps": [ { "id": "real-low-audio", "status": "unfilled", "description": "No defensible low-craft audiobook example with verified AI-generated writing was established by this bounded search. Synthetic defects test the low end without alleging facts about a real author." }, { "id": "heldout-real-set", "status": "unfilled", "description": "The named series informed calibration. A separate independently reviewed real holdout has not been collected; neither visible synthetic controls nor matching the anchors establishes empirical accuracy." }, { "id": "later-volume-evidence", "status": "requires-acquisition", "description": "Heretical Fishing decline is a user-reported hypothesis. Comparable early, middle, and late volume craft evidence is required before measuring it." }, { "id": "author-targets", "status": "unfilled", "description": "No author-wide benchmark was inferred from the four series preferences, and no canonical author IDs were fabricated where the local author table lacked them." } ], "syntheticCraftProfiles": { "profile-1": { "scores": { "prose": 90, "editing": 90, "coherence": 90, "structure": 90, "pacing": 90, "repetition": 90 }, "confidence": 0.95, "voices": 10 }, "profile-2": { "scores": { "prose": 15, "editing": 10, "coherence": 10, "structure": 15, "pacing": 20, "repetition": 5 }, "confidence": 0.95, "voices": 10 }, "profile-3": { "scores": { "prose": 90, "editing": 90, "coherence": 90, "structure": 90, "pacing": 90, "repetition": 90 }, "confidence": 0.95, "voices": 1 }, "profile-4": { "scores": {}, "confidence": 0.95, "voices": 0 }, "profile-5": { "scores": { "prose": 92, "editing": 92, "coherence": 92, "structure": 92, "pacing": 92, "repetition": 92 }, "confidence": 0.95, "voices": 10 }, "profile-6": { "scores": { "prose": 88, "editing": 88, "coherence": 88, "structure": 88, "pacing": 88, "repetition": 88 }, "confidence": 0.95, "voices": 10 }, "profile-7": { "scores": { "prose": 65, "editing": 65, "coherence": 65, "structure": 65, "pacing": 65, "repetition": 65 }, "confidence": 0.95, "voices": 10 }, "profile-8": { "scores": { "prose": 55, "editing": 55, "coherence": 55, "structure": 55, "pacing": 55, "repetition": 55 }, "confidence": 0.95, "voices": 10 }, "profile-9": { "scores": { "prose": 60, "editing": 60, "coherence": 60, "structure": 60, "pacing": 60, "repetition": 60 }, "confidence": 0.95, "voices": 10 } }, "syntheticProfileExpansion": { "description": "Expand each input.craftProfile into CraftInput before using the scoring API. Profile scores apply only to these invented cases.", "evidenceIds": "For each book, generate profile.voices unique synthetic::voice-<1-based-index> IDs; use these same unique IDs across dimensions rather than adding their counts.", "voiceAccounting": "Each listed dimension has judgedVoices=voices. For score>=60 use positiveVoices=voices; score<40 negativeVoices=voices; otherwise mixedVoices=voices. Set the other two counts to zero. relevantVoices=voices. Unknown profiles with no scores have dimensions={}.", "confidence": "Use the declared confidence for each dimension. All scores and counts are invented fixture data, not model outcomes." } }