- Issues
- #129
Docs: a hosted quickstart for people without an S3 bucket?
hmseeb opened ยท
Asking before writing anything, since PRs are disabled and I'd rather not spend your review time on a patch you don't want.
**The gap:** `Run it` needs an S3-compatible bucket and a working AWS credential chain before celld will start. That's correct for operators, but it's a wall for anyone who just wants to see celld serve something before deciding whether to invest in it. `Install` gets you a binary in seconds; the first actual run is a much bigger step.
**What I'd propose:** a short `## Hosted` section between `Run it` and `Operate a fleet` โ five or six lines plus a deploy button. One click provisions a bucket, wires `CELLD_BUCKET`, `S3_ENDPOINT`, `AWS_REGION` and the access keys into the container, and runs the published `ghcr.io/denoland/celld` image. `celld deploy` from a local checkout into the same bucket is unchanged, so it's an on-ramp to the documented workflow rather than a parallel one.
No fork and no wrapper image โ it runs your published release image as-is. I'd mark it community-maintained, not an official Deno build.
**Disclosure:** I maintain the template and Railway pays template authors a share of what deployments spend, so I'm not a neutral party here. Judge it on whether it's useful to people evaluating celld.
If you want it, I'll send a `git format-patch` to ry@deno.com under the CLA terms in the README. If not, closing this costs you one click and I won't push further.
- SH
`rclone serve s3` is working with celld ```sh $ tree ./celld-s3/ ./celld-s3/ โโโ celld $ rclone serve s3 --addr :9090 ./celld-s3 # another shell $ export AWS_ACCESS_KEY_ID=a $ export AWS_SECRET_ACCESS_KEY=b $ celld deploy --bucket 's3://celld' --endpoint 'http://127.0.0.1:9090' $ celld --bucket 's3://celld' --endpoint 'http://127.0.0.1:9090' ```
----
v0.2.0 fixed
----
<del>but counter example is failed:</del> ```log celld restore failed for Counter:32f7ce5ceac27cc99133a1a2d4a0755904ed511d7d07ca992b97f425f80cb53a: restore Counter:32f7ce5ceac27cc99133a1a2d4a0755904ed511d7d07ca992b97f425f80cb53a e1: open ltx file: Generic S3 error: Received non-partial response when range requested ```
- MA
@shynome The ranged-read failure you hit is gone as of **v0.2.0**: `548002b5` removed ranged reads from the LTX client, so celld no longer asks for a partial response. `rclone serve s3` is worth retrying on that release. The issue's own question โ a hosted quickstart โ is still open and separate.
shynomementioned3 months ago on GitHub
shynomesubscribed3 months ago on GitHub
- DP
i made https://github.com/dpsutton/celld-local for precisely this purpose. It runs an s3 compatible service backed by local filesystem, finds open ports and runs all of this for you.
<img width="1300" height="950" alt="Image" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/6840ed36-5788-41fb-8c9f-8ff5548a98f0" />
This always prints out what it's doing for you so all of this gets out of your way now but it's never magic you can't understand. It's got the commands and the output of those present.
I also have `celld-local deploy` which tries to figure out and build your project and then redeploys.
This works in all of the examples in the celld repository.
- BA
I'd say this is now covered as of v0.4.0 with `celld dev` subcommand.